Copper Magazine · Issue 232 · A free PS Audio publication
Issue 232 Featured

Creed Over Camaraderie?

Creed Over Camaraderie?

A few years ago, I convinced a friend to attend our weekly “Tea Parties.” Tristan’s never been much of a social butterfly and I was hoping to make his senior years more enjoyable.

We tend to discuss any and all subjects at these sessions including religion and politics. Such dialog can be stimulating and informative so long as it remains rational and civil – which should come naturally to mature friends.

But instead of contributing his point of view, he kept silent and seethed under his breath whenever the conversation challenged his creed. After a few weeks, he “cancelled” his participation in the Tea Parties and its organizer – me. Cancellation is the current euphemism for ostracizing someone who doesn’t share your ideology.

In his e-mail, he wrote, “I don't think I can be friends with anyone who harbors your beliefs.”

If we’d become friends recently, maybe I’d understand, but we’ve been going to audio shows together for decades. If I’d changed my views during that time, maybe he’d be justified, but I've been consistent since the day we met. So either he’s changed his dogma, or he’s become more radicalized.

Cancellation has been practiced for centuries by political and religious organizations. Sanctimonious patriarchs excommunicated truth-tellers like Socrates, Galileo, Spinoza, Luther, and Kepler rather than re-evaluate their world view.

Countless families and social groups today are equally sanctimonious. Rather than engage in productive dialog to foster understanding, they employ insults, ad hominem attacks, and cancellation.

It’s one thing to harbor a dogma, it’s another to prioritize it over people. A dogma won’t fetch a stick, share a beer, or engage in meaningful conversation. Taken to the extreme, dogma can become fanaticism.

The Crusaders of the 12th century justified looting, burning, and killing by insisting that they held the moral high ground. Today’s moral crusaders do exactly the same thing. Do they really believe that anarchy is the way to promote tolerance and inclusion? That’s like sponsoring spring break to promote celibacy.

Jesus preached, “Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God.” – Matthew 5:9

The Buddha contended that “attachment is the cause of all suffering.” If history is any indication, that’s especially true of attachment to dogma.

Julian Braebourne wrote, “Prioritizing creed over camaraderie is a pretentious conceit which always leads to conflict.”

The regulars at our Tea Party understand that. Perhaps, one day, Tristan will too.

 

Luncheon of the Boating Party by Pierre-Auguste Renoir. Courtesy of Wikipedia/public domain.

 

Header image courtesy of B. Jan Montana.

More from Issue 232

View All Articles in Issue 232

Search Copper Magazine

#236 Magic Boy: The Jimi Hendrix Experience, Live and Rediscovered by Frank Doris Nov 02, 2026 #236 The Great Rhythmic Divide: Composer David Chesky Asks, Why Doesn't the Symphony Orchestra Groove? by David Chesky Nov 02, 2026 #236 More Record Reviews: Roni Eytan’s Microtonal Harmonica, Jane Ira Bloom, and a Frank Zappa Freak Out by Frank Doris Nov 02, 2026 #236 An Album of Inviting Beauty: Goodnight Moon from Acoustic Eidolon, And an Interview With the Artists Who Created it by Frank Doris Nov 02, 2026 #236 Never Ignore Your Inner Voice by B. Jan Montana Nov 02, 2026 #236 Composer Joseph Bertolozzi Uses Bridges, Structures and the World as Musical Instruments, Part One by Joe Caplan Nov 02, 2026 #236 Transmission: A Powerful Horn-Loaded Album from the Huntertones by Ray Chelstowski Nov 02, 2026 #236 Les Quatre Saisons du Québec: a New “Four Seasons” on Tour and on ATMA Classique by Robert Schryer Nov 02, 2026 #236 From The Audiophile's Guide: A Glossary of Terms for Today's Audio Systems, A – M by Paul McGowan Nov 02, 2026 #236 From The Listening Chair: An Introduction to Audiophile Tweaks by Howard Kneller Nov 02, 2026 #236 The Vinyl Beat Grew Two Inches Since October! by Rudy Radelic Nov 02, 2026 #236 How to Play in a Rock Band, Part 29: Figuring Out How to Play the Songs by Frank Doris Nov 02, 2026 #236 The Return of the Residents: Eskimo is On the Road by Wayne Robins Nov 02, 2026 #236 PS Audio in the News by PS Audio Staff Nov 02, 2026 #236 The People Who Make Audio Happen – Fun In Las Vegas at…CES 2026? by Harris Fogel Nov 02, 2026 #236 The Forms of Things Unknown by Frank Doris Nov 02, 2026 #236 Prophetic by Peter Xeni Nov 02, 2026 #236 Here's Looking at You, Kid by Rich Isaacs Nov 02, 2026 Favorites From T.H.E. Show SoCal 2026 by Cam Martin Oct 05, 2026 #235 Singer/Songwriter John David Schrader: On the Need to Create, Part Two by Joe Caplan Oct 05, 2026 #235 A Life in High-End Audio: The Roy Hall Interview, Part Two by Frank Doris Oct 05, 2026 #235 Grammy-Winning Producer, Songwriter, and Guitarist John Leventhal Goes Instrumental With National Drift by Ray Chelstowski Oct 05, 2026 #235 From Swimming Pool to New Listening Room—to Founding an Accidental Audio Company by Gilles Laferrière Oct 05, 2026 #235 The Vinyl Beat’s Size Matters Edition by Rudy Radelic Oct 05, 2026 #235 The Sublime Complexities of Nature by B. Jan Montana Oct 05, 2026 #235 How to Play In a Rock Band, 28: Growing Older and Dealing With It by Frank Doris Oct 05, 2026 #235 Young Rascals: From Bar Band to Stardom by Wayne Robins Oct 05, 2026 #235 Duncan Sheik: In Memoriam by Ray Chelstowski Oct 05, 2026 #235 From The Listening Chair: The Meze Audio 105 Silva Headphones by Howard Kneller Oct 05, 2026 #235 Checking Out Some NOLA Loudspeakers – and Some Thoughts About Audio Writing by Frank Doris Oct 05, 2026 #235 The Kanazawa Phonograph Museum: Music from a Time Capsule by Sebastian Polcyn Oct 05, 2026 #235 PS Audio in the News by PS Audio Staff Oct 05, 2026 #235 From The Audiophile’s Guide: Making the Most Critical Choice by Paul McGowan Oct 05, 2026 #235 Evolutionary Growth by Frank Doris Oct 05, 2026 #235 Speed Racer by Peter Xeni Oct 05, 2026 #235 Happy Halloween! by James Schrimpf Oct 05, 2026 #234 A Life in High-End Audio: The Roy Hall Interview, Part One by Frank Doris Sep 07, 2026 #234 Jason Greenlaw Offers His Personal Perspective on Jazz Guitar in Vantage Point by Frank Doris Sep 07, 2026 #234 Transcendent Phoenix: Lucina Yue Brings the Ancient Konghou Into Modern Times by Frank Doris Sep 07, 2026 #234 We Must All Follow Our Bliss by B. Jan Montana Sep 07, 2026 #234 How to Play in a Rock Band, 27: Leveling Up by Frank Doris Sep 07, 2026 #234 Ross Valory: Traveling Into New Musical Territory With All of the Above by Ray Chelstowski Sep 07, 2026 #234 Singer/Songwriter John David Schrader: On the Need to Create by Joe Caplan Sep 07, 2026 #234 The People Who Make Audio Happen: More From T.H.E. Show SoCal 2026 by Harris Fogel Sep 07, 2026 #234 The Vinyl Beat Digs Into the Gadget Box by Rudy Radelic Sep 07, 2026 #234 The Rolling Stones: Foreign Tongues Spoken Loud by Wayne Robins Sep 07, 2026 #234 Musical Moments by Rich Isaacs Sep 07, 2026

Creed Over Camaraderie?

Creed Over Camaraderie?

A few years ago, I convinced a friend to attend our weekly “Tea Parties.” Tristan’s never been much of a social butterfly and I was hoping to make his senior years more enjoyable.

We tend to discuss any and all subjects at these sessions including religion and politics. Such dialog can be stimulating and informative so long as it remains rational and civil – which should come naturally to mature friends.

But instead of contributing his point of view, he kept silent and seethed under his breath whenever the conversation challenged his creed. After a few weeks, he “cancelled” his participation in the Tea Parties and its organizer – me. Cancellation is the current euphemism for ostracizing someone who doesn’t share your ideology.

In his e-mail, he wrote, “I don't think I can be friends with anyone who harbors your beliefs.”

If we’d become friends recently, maybe I’d understand, but we’ve been going to audio shows together for decades. If I’d changed my views during that time, maybe he’d be justified, but I've been consistent since the day we met. So either he’s changed his dogma, or he’s become more radicalized.

Cancellation has been practiced for centuries by political and religious organizations. Sanctimonious patriarchs excommunicated truth-tellers like Socrates, Galileo, Spinoza, Luther, and Kepler rather than re-evaluate their world view.

Countless families and social groups today are equally sanctimonious. Rather than engage in productive dialog to foster understanding, they employ insults, ad hominem attacks, and cancellation.

It’s one thing to harbor a dogma, it’s another to prioritize it over people. A dogma won’t fetch a stick, share a beer, or engage in meaningful conversation. Taken to the extreme, dogma can become fanaticism.

The Crusaders of the 12th century justified looting, burning, and killing by insisting that they held the moral high ground. Today’s moral crusaders do exactly the same thing. Do they really believe that anarchy is the way to promote tolerance and inclusion? That’s like sponsoring spring break to promote celibacy.

Jesus preached, “Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God.” – Matthew 5:9

The Buddha contended that “attachment is the cause of all suffering.” If history is any indication, that’s especially true of attachment to dogma.

Julian Braebourne wrote, “Prioritizing creed over camaraderie is a pretentious conceit which always leads to conflict.”

The regulars at our Tea Party understand that. Perhaps, one day, Tristan will too.

 

Luncheon of the Boating Party by Pierre-Auguste Renoir. Courtesy of Wikipedia/public domain.

 

Header image courtesy of B. Jan Montana.

0 comments

Leave a comment

0 Comments

Your avatar

Loading comments...

🗑️ Delete Comment

Enter moderator password to delete this comment:

✏️ Edit Comment

Enter your email to verify ownership: