People love to argue about whether vinyl sounds "better" than digital. I think that misses the point entirely. Vinyl doesn't sound better or worse.
It sounds different.
Understanding why it sounds different is far more interesting than picking a winner.
Let's start with what's physically happening. A diamond stylus is dragging through a groove that's been cut into a piece of plastic. The groove walls wiggle in a pattern that mirrors the original sound wave — literally a physical analogy of the music. The cartridge converts those mechanical vibrations into an electrical signal, and your phono stage amplifies it.
Vinyl is an analog chain from start to finish. And analog chains have a particular character that comes (in part) from harmonic distortion. Not a lot, but it's there, and it tends to be predominantly even-order — second harmonic, fourth harmonic. Our ears find even-order harmonics pleasant. They add a sense of richness and body that our brains interpret as natural.
More than anything it's the mechanical nature of the playback system—just like loudspeakers—that are all over the map when it comes to sonic character.
Then there's the physical ritual. Cleaning the record, lowering the tonearm, watching the platter spin. I
Does this mean vinyl is "better"? Not in any measurable, objective sense (in fact it's worse). A well-recorded DSD file has far more dynamic range, lower noise, and wider bandwidth.
Vinyl sounds the way it sounds because of physics, chemistry, and a bit of human psychology.
And for many of us, that combination is simply irresistible.
0 comments